The Big Picture In India’s rapidly evolving economy, a critical battle is playing out – small and medium enterprises (SMEs) are struggling to keep up with the innovation race while large companies surge ahead. This story explores how India’s small businesses are navigating the challenging world of research and development (R&D) in an increasingly competitive global market.
Setting the Stage: A Changed World The 1990s brought dramatic changes to India’s business landscape:
- Reduced government protection for small businesses
- Increased foreign competition
- Stricter intellectual property rules
- Cheaper imports flooding markets
- Limited access to resources and funding
The Innovation Gap: Tale of Two Business Worlds
Large Companies:
- 38% conduct regular R&D
- Increasing R&D investment (up 39% in 2000s)
- Average 0.38% of sales spent on R&D
- Leading innovation across sectors
Small & Medium Businesses:
- Only 8.5% of small firms do R&D
- 16% of medium firms invest in R&D
- R&D spending declined in 2000s
- Struggle with limited resources
- Focus on survival over innovation
The R&D Champions Among SMEs
When small businesses do invest in R&D, they often outperform larger firms. The most successful SME innovators share key characteristics:
- Battle-Tested Veterans
- Older firms with accumulated experience
- Established market presence
- Deeper industry knowledge
- Global Competitors
- Active in export markets
- Source materials internationally
- Exposed to global best practices
- Strategic Partnerships
- Connected to business groups
- Foreign investment/partnerships
- Access to wider resources
- Financial Strength
- Higher profit margins
- Internal funding capacity
- Better access to capital
Sector Stories: Where Small Innovation Thrives
Top SME R&D sectors:
- Chemicals and pharmaceuticals
- Electrical and optical equipment
- Machinery and equipment
- Transport equipment
What Makes These Sectors Different:
- Technology-intensive nature
- Higher innovation opportunities
- Better returns on R&D
- Strategic importance
The Path Forward: Policy Implications
Essential Steps to Boost SME Innovation:
- Access to Resources
- Easier access to capital markets
- Venture capital funding
- R&D-specific financing
- Collaboration Support
- Industrial clustering promotion
- Research partnerships
- Knowledge sharing networks
- Global Integration
- Export promotion
- International sourcing support
- Technology transfer facilitation
- Strategic Investment
- Increased equity participation limits
- Foreign investment promotion
- Business group partnerships
Key Takeaways
For Policymakers:
- Focus on financial access
- Promote clustering
- Support international engagement
- Enable strategic partnerships
For SME Leaders:
- Build global connections
- Seek strategic partners
- Focus on profitable niches
- Leverage experience advantages
For Researchers:
- Track sectoral differences
- Study successful cases
- Monitor policy impacts
- Analyze collaboration effects
The Bigger Question Can India maintain its economic momentum without bringing its small businesses into the innovation fold? The future may depend on bridging the growing R&D divide between large and small enterprises.
Academic Abstract:
Liberalisation of economic policies in the last two decades and intensifying market competition tend to be a cause of policy concern for the survival of SMEs in emerging economies like India. These SMEs account for the largest chunk of industrial units and employment in the national economy. Yet, most of them are competing with deeply inadequate resources, especially by means of weak technological capabilities. The present study has provided not only preliminary estimates on SME R&D investments in Indian manufacturing and their broad trends and patterns, but also contributed to the understanding of factors driving the SME in-house R&D activities. It shows that Indian SMEs continue to be vulnerable among all fi rms as they have the lowest incidence of doing in-house R&D and their R&D intensities have fallen in the last decade. Based on the results from three-step Censored Quantile Regression, this study has suggested a set of useful policy implications for enhancing SME R&D.
Learn More:
Full citation: Pradhan, Jaya Prakash (2011), ‘R&D Strategy of Small and Medium Enterprises in India’, Science, Technology & Society, 16(3), pp. 373–395, Publisher: SAGE Publications.
Learn More:
